So, I go really, really hard on Canon in this. The context is that Canon openly admitted to having fascist leanings. I posted on Twitter saying, yeah, an East Asian likes fascism. We knew this, especially since she's been openly transphobic this entire dang time. But naw, people be shocked that the transphobic Japanese lady likes fascism.
Forgotten Friday #123 - v.m.g.のシナ / Shina
Who is Shina?
official art from bank |
Everyone is allowed to dress however they like. I'm a Drag Race fan. So, why am I giving this UTAU a pass when I have openly called Canon transphobic?
Because Ritsu is a joke. Ritsu is meant to be laughed at. Canon hasn't told people to stop using transphobic language around Ritsu. Ritsu has emboldened other people to be transphobic. This is all very bad, and okama is a slur.
Shina isn't referred to with a blatant slur. As far as I know, 男の娘 may be slang, but it's not a slur to the degree that okama is.
I don't know who made him or why, but the in universe reason for why Shina cross dresses is really, uh… sweet in the Southern Gothic sense. His sister, who he loved dearly, passed. He tries to keep her alive in any way that he can by imitating her appearance as best as he can. He is thirteen years old and his race is listed as demon.
Shina has troubles in life. He goes around with his chest puffed out, insulting those around him. But he does it to hide the fact that he is lonely, miserable, and can't be honest. Is this hinting that he may be an egg?
Don't get your hopes up. Japan still really sucks about trans issues. I wanted to read up and give examples, but I had to stop and just stare at nothing for a bit. Their shiny new law that goes in to place in 2022 requires irreversible and permanent sterilization to change your sex legally.
I mean, that sucks. Everyone experiences dysphoria in different ways. Some people can love their bodies if they can function in the role of the gender they know they are. They can go on to have babies and love the babies.
Many trans people hate everything about the gender they were assigned at birth. They would happily jump at sterilization if it gets them closer to the body they were meant to have.
You might notice that I'm projecting Western ideals onto a character who was not created with those in mind. The person who made him may have actually been trying to copy Ritsu. But the thing is that the text doesn't support the idea that this character is a bad joke. And that's the issue with Ritsu: is a six year old with triple Gs that loves North Korea and the gender is a slur.
I can't get that from the text of Shina's biography.
No comments:
Post a Comment